Franchise Mode has long been a staple in MLB The Show, and player ratings play a central role in every decision you make—from trades and mlb stubscontracts to rotations and lineups. The top 10 rated players in The Show 25 aren’t just stars—they’re investments.

Signing or trading for Shohei Ohtani in Franchise Mode is like hitting the lottery. His bat alone offers MVP-level stats, and with proper recovery from injury, he might return to pitching in future seasons. He boosts attendance, morale, and on-field production.

Juan Soto and Aaron Judge are power anchors. Teams built around their bats can generate massive offensive production. But they’re also expensive in long-term contracts, especially in simulation models. Proper salary management becomes critical if you’re trying to build around one of these megastars.

Players like Ketel Marte and Mookie Betts offer rare value. They combine high ratings with versatility, meaning they can adapt to team injuries, lineup changes, or even aging stars. Their WAR (Wins Above Replacement) over multiple years keeps your team competitive.

Pitchers like Burnes and Cole offer dependable starts and postseason experience, which matter in sim engine logic. Burnes’ low walk and high strikeout rates simulate well, often landing him Cy Young consideration in long-term Franchises.

Building around these players means crafting a team identity—whether it’s a slugging powerhouse or a defensively dominant infield. Either way, the Top 10 players in MLB The Show 25 can be the core of your dynasty.